Andrew Lloyd Webber Calls a 'Masked Singer' Contestant's Performance of His Song 'Absolutely Wonderful'

This post contains spoilers from Wednesday’s episode ofThe Masked Singer.

Broadway greatness came toThe Masked SingerforAndrew Lloyd WebberNight Wednedsay.

The English composer, 74, even showed up for the occasion and joinedKen Jeong,Jenny McCarthy,Nicole ScherzingerandRobin Thickeon the panel.

“I moved to the city and struggled to find my place in this business of show,” the corn said.

Michael Becker/FOX

The package also featured a yellow bird, the Statue of Liberty and a calendar with a wedding cake on it.

Maize sang “Heaven on Their Minds” fromJesus Christ Superstar.

The judges guessedMatthew Broderick,Mario Cantone,Jonathan GroffandNathan Lane.

Mermaid swam onto the stage next.

“It wasn’t a straight shot to success,” Mermaid said in her clue package that included two white birds, a record and a movie score. “Right when my career was just taking off, a horrible accident led to a major setback. I was petrified I would never be the same, let alone preform, but God had greater plans for me.”

The majestic sea creature additionally teased being “a big a legend as you are Lloyd Webber.”

Mermaid’s post performance clue stated that she had entered Library of Congress.

Cher,Gloria Estefan,Roberta FlackandGloria Gaynorall came up as possibilities for Mermaid.

RELATED VIDEO: Hayley Orrantia Compares Her Time on Masked SingertoX Factor: ‘It’s Surreal’

Last up: Robo Girl.

“Stepping up into the spotlight on Andrew Lloyd Webber Night feels a little out of my comfort zone,” Robo Girl admitted in her clue package. “‘Cause for much of my career, I’ve lived in the shadow of superstars.”

The package showed a surfboard and two jars of honey and mentioned a stage name.

“With 86 cents to my name, I booked a job that changed my life forever,” Robo Girl said, adding, “I not only found my own pretty little spotlight, but gained the most magical fandom in the world. They’ve given me supernatural confidence.”

Robo Girl belted “Bad Cinderella” fromBad Cinderella.

“I watched you and I thought of a margarita,” said Scherzinger, 44.

Robo Girl’s additional clue teased, “While on tour, Robo Girl holds her own opposite multi-Grammy winner.”

The panel tossed outCara Delevingne,Jenna Dewan,Becky G,Selena Gomez,Lucy HaleandKeke Palmerfor Robo Girl’s possible identity.

HostNick Cannonannounced that the time had come for the studio audience and panel to vote for their favorite performance of the night. The contestant who received the fewest number of votes would immediately unmask — the other two would face off in a Battle Royale.

Cannon, 41, revealed Maize would go home first. And underneath the corny costume poppedSex and the City’s Cantone, 62.

Michael Becker/FOX, Stefanie Keenan/Getty

Then Robo Girl and Mermaid belted “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” fromEvita, and the judges decided Mermaid should move on. Accordingly, Lloyd Webber deemed Robo Girl the new reigning queen.

Upon being unmasked, another one of the panel’s earlier guesses — “I Will Survive” singer Gaynor — appeared.

“I love you all,” the two-time Grammy winner, 79, said to her fans. “Keep watching, keeping living and most of all, keeping love.”

Michael Becker/FOX, Jamie McCarthy/Getty

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up to date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The Masked Singerairs Wednesdays at 8 p.m. ET on Fox.

source: people.com